Miami-Dade superintendent Alberto Carvalho made the pitch to the state board of education last week that Florida must pause its multiple accountability systems:
Carvalho said the proposal would make it clear which schools and districts were performing well and which were not.
“There is a way of creating a transitional accountability system,” he said, “that includes a direct, legible and easily-understood school report card for parents and business leaders without necessarily imposing a letter grade during the transitional period.”
Carvalho also urged the board to reconsider the state’s teacher evaluation rules and the reliance on a statistical formula which determines teacher performance, known as Value-Added Measure, or VAM.
“VAM is not understood by teachers,” he said. “And you and I know if it’s not understood, it is not trusted.”
Funny you don’t hear about VAM or its “merit pay” structure from Florida republican legislators as it’s supposed to start next year when SB 736 is to be fully implemented. Oh, there’s been plenty of happy talk about charter schools and school choice, but not so much about the bill that’s ironically called “the Student Success Act.”
Wasn’t it supposed to be about kids? Remember when SB 736 sponsor, Sen. Steve Wise wailed in 2011 that “kids would be irreparably harmed,” if his bill wasn’t passed?
There’s an election this year. And the guy who signed the bill, Rick Scott, is going to get hammered by Charlie Crist – who vetoed a similar bill and Nan Rich who recommended to that blow hard Wise, that we should see what happens with the Hillsborough pilot program first.
Republican legislators – and Scott – know the fight on common core and its new tests is a loser for them. No sense bringing up their other bad ideas right now.