Why Alan Hays Pulled His Amendment Which Protected Florida Students From Invalid FSA Tests

During yesterday’s Senate Appropriations Committee hearing, and quick little sidebar away from the microphones occurred between four senators. The sponsor of the senate version (SB 616) of high-stakes testing reform, Senator John Legg was huddled with Senator’s David Simmons, Bill Galvano, and Alan Hays. The later, Hays, had filed an amendment to Legg’s bill which would have ended 3rd grade retentions and hold harmless all stakeholders from the results of new FSA tests until they were found to be valid.

A few minutes later, Hays pulled his amendment in favor of a watered down amendment by Simmons. Galvano was there to tell his republican colleague that he didn’t have the votes and Simmons made sure that Hays had a way to save face. Legg was there because it was his bill and he had obviously informed Hays that he was going to classify his amendment as an unfriendly one.

During Hays remarks surrounding his amendment and his decision to pull it, it was clear he believed in it. Maybe Simmons did, too. But because there weren’t enough republican votes for it yesterday in Appropriations, that it was best that it not suffer a defeat. Hence, the senate has the spirit of Hays amendment in its place in the form of Simmons’ amendment.

Legg later reportedly refused to meet with a group of parents because they weren’t from his district. They met with Legg’s chief of staff, Jim Browne instead. When addressing the parents concerns about special populations among the bottom 20 percent of a bell curve, Browne curiously replied that “they didn’t care about the bottom 2o percent.”

The words of Legg’s chief of staff indicate that Legg and republican leadership don’t want to be challenged on FSA validity in general and 3rd grade retention in particular even in the face of real test validity issues. While Simmons has done a good job of pointing out to his colleagues that FSA has real validity problems and that Pam Stewart’s FDOE isn’t being entirely candid, he’s not known to bucking leadership. But Hays will.

It’s fair to wonder whether or not Hays thought back yesterday to 2012 when he told Jeb Bush, “No.” Hays had been a sponsor of a controversial parent trigger bill but voted against the bill in a dispute with then senate president Mike Hairodololis.  Bush dispatched an influential member of Hays’ community, Gary Lester, VP of the Villages retirement community  to call on Hays. Hays held firm.

Bush later attributed the defeat – via a 20-20 tie – was due to the senate’s “Byzantine traditions.” Odd for a guy who doesn’t mind being referred to as Veto Corleone. In 2012, Bush Corleone sent Luca Brasi from the Villages to make Hays an offer he couldn’t refuse, but Hays refused. Who could blame Hays if he thought Bush just used other lieutenants yesterday.

Hays has a lot on his plate during this session – he was ripped by the Ocala Star-Banner  today in his role as chairman of the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on General Government, so he cannot be blamed for looking to do a little horse trading. But Hays has demonstrated that he will take on the big boys and it was quite clear yesterday that he believed in his amendment.

Somehow, you just know Hays’ amendment will make its way to the senate floor. A vote by Bush’s lieutenants against Hays amendment or even Simmons’ watered down version  will show they aren’t concerned about FSA’s validity and what it might mean for Florida kids.




About Bob Sikes

A long time ago and a planet far, far away I was an athletic trainer for the New York Mets. I was blessed to be part of the now legendary 1986 World Series Championship. My late father told me that I'd one day be thankful I had that degree in teaching from Florida State University. He was right and I became twice blesses to become a teacher in the late 1990's. After dabbling with writing about the Mets and then politics, I settled on education.
This entry was posted in EDUCATION, Florida, FLORIDA POLITICS and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Why Alan Hays Pulled His Amendment Which Protected Florida Students From Invalid FSA Tests

  1. Ro says:

    It’s time for parents to lawyer up. I am tired of the punitive nature and the denial of my son’s civil rights and the complete lack of care by these guys. They haven’t seen anything like a pack of pissed off mama bears.

    • Terry says:

      It’s essential for parents to keep the pressure on! When teachers and their unions protest, they’re accused of not wanting to be held accountable. If some of these legislators are voted out of office, others might get the message.

  2. Go for it ‘Mama Bear’. It is about time that women stood up for their children against the Patriarchy. Things have not changed( as many think) since the times when fathers, through their economic arguments, commonly convinced their wives to have another baby because ‘they needed more help to run the family farm’. Unfortunately, many men are still of the same mentality (also shared by many women in their dreams of their children going to college and becoming ‘my son the doctor (or Wall Street Broker)’, due in part to the aggressive, competitive society that we live in. You are part of a revolution that will shake the foundations of our society, hopefully before we allow these distorted people from destroying the support systems we need to survive on this planet.

  3. Mark Halpert says:

    Excellent posting — we at the Learning Disabilities Association of Florida really do care about the bottom 20% as do many others and you Bob. Bob — do you have a source for this comment
    They met with Legg’s chief of staff, Jim Browne instead. When addressing the parents concerns about special populations among the bottom 20 percent of a bell curve, Browne curiously replied that “they didn’t care about the bottom 20 percent.”

  4. Pingback: What did Florida senators do about third grade retentions? Other education news… | CTA

  5. Leadership is lock step with Jeb Bush and his race for president. Shudder the thought! They are willing to have 2.7 million children as collateral damage, and THEY KNOW full well all the reasons we oppose Common Core and high stakes testing. We need to seriously rain on their parade and kick them out. Blaize Ingoglia is in on the deal, too. He’s the new head of the RPOF who is also a freshman in the state legislature, and he got there by promising he would not interfere in the primary elections. What’s the FIRST thing he did? Move the primary to make them “winner take all” to suit Jeb Bush. Are you TIRED of backroom deals? I’m going to drive 6 hours to Tallahassee and tell them all about it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s